Pinelli wrote an article for The Second Fireside Book of Baseball, titled "Kill the Umpire? Don\'t Make Me Laugh!" in which he told about his rookie year of 1935, when he was told that he should not call a strike on Babe Ruth, who was winding up his career with the Boston Braves. Pinelli did not see it that way. When he was behind the plate and Ruth came to bat, and a close pitch went by at which Ruth did not swing, Pinelli deemed it a strike and so called it. Ruth turned to the umpire and bellowed, "There\'s forty thousand people in this park that know that was a ball, tomato-head!" Pinelli did not lose his cool. He replied calmly, "Perhaps—but mine is the only opinion that counts." Ruth had no answer for that.\n', '

His final game as a home plate umpire provided an extraordinary capstone to his career. He was behind the plate for Don Larsen\'s perfect Game 5 in the 1956 World Series. His final call as a plate ump presumably was "Strike 3! You\'re out!" to pinch-hitter Dale Mitchell. Pinelli later recalled that after the game, he returned to the umpires\' room and burst into tears. It has often been reported that that was Pinelli\'s final game as an umpire, but that is incorrect; Pinelli was a field umpire for the final two games of the Series, and then called it a career.\n', '

In his book The Game of Baseball, Gil Hodges recounted a story of how, while dressing for a game, he and several other Brooklyn Dodgers debated which umpires were most likely and least likely to eject a player from a game. Hodges recalled that Pee Wee Reese expressed the opinion that Pinelli was the umpire least likely to throw a player out. Reese was indeed ejected from that day\'s game—by Pinelli.\n', '

Return to Babe Pinelli Autograph Profile